“What are you, on your period or something?” This is what a teenage boy might ask Hilary Duff of her latest teenage angst filled release, Dignity. This title would usually be absurd, but given the recent antics of her panty-less, rehab-entering colleagues, (LiLo, Brit –I’m looking at you) Hilary seems to be doing a pretty good job of keeping her dignity in tact and keeping her underwear on. I’m still not sure if Dignity is the word to describe it, but with this electro-pop album, Hilary Duff certainly sheds her Lizzie McGuire image like a size AA Hanes-Her-Way training bra.
Hilary’s latest album is a perky “You go girl!” for the 12-16 year old bracket. Where she used to “let the rain fall down” and splash about in the puddles, Hilary now stomps angrily and lets her mascara smear. She sings of her breakup with Good Charlotte’s Joel Madden on “Stranger,” the deep-breathing types of her older male fan base on “Danger,” and of breakups again on the I’m-like-so-totally-over-you song, “Happy.” Joel, who could easily get in an eyeliner-off with both Duff sisters, seems to have left the young, nubile Hil in a state of rage, providing much fodder for her lyrics: they read like the emo poems from the Hello Kitty diary of a high school prom queen stood up by her date. We gotta cut Hil some slack: he did ditch her for a stick figure who once drove the wrong way on a freeway while stoned out of her gourd.
On this album, it seems like the princess of bubblegum seems to have lost some of her pop. The synth beats are of the bad 80s kind, especially on “Never Stop,” and the single, “With Love.” Both sound like demo’s you might find on a Casio keyboard at a garage sale. Hilary would have a hit on her hands had she stuck with the rock based belters that she’s known for. These radio hits usually let her hang out with the older kids, the post-sweet-16 crowd who aren’t ashamed to enjoy songs like her past hits “Come Clean” (better known by its chorus “let the rain fall down”) and “So Yesterday.” Dignity doesn’t contain a single song like this, save the title track. Hil should’ve given us a hit that we could sing in the shower. You know, the jump-around-your-room-in-your-underwear-singing-into-a-hairbrush kind of pop song.
Dignity is Hilary’s equivalent of the “Not a girl, not yet a woman” stage that Britney Spears went through not too long ago. The album is dressing up in the makeup and high heels of an older, sexier euro-pop album: everything is two sizes too big and slightly ridiculous sounding. Albums like this only seem to work when highly sexual songstresses are at the helm (see: Madonna’s Confessions on a Dance Floor and any Kylie Minogue). For once, Hilary Duff’s status as the reigning virginal, pre-pubescent teen queen plays against her. It’s hard to imagine this being played in a club. It’s easy to imagine it bumping out of a plastic Mattel jukebox.
- Celeste Ballard
